In Her Defense is a 1998 thriller directed by Sidney J. Furie. Lawyer Andrew Garfield begins having an affair with a deaf woman, played by Marlee Matlin, when one day her husband catches them. Andrew Garfield then kills him. From … Marlee Matlin, Daniel Pilon, Michael Dudikoff, Sophie Lorain, David Attis, Stephen Morgan, Doug Sutherland Added on Amazon Prime 2022-01-02.